Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   Stillman's (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/stillmans/)
-   -   HCG vs. QWL (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/stillmans/728769-hcg-vs-qwl.html)

doxielove 07-19-2011 04:51 PM

HCG vs. QWL
 
Hi Friends,

I have been doing hcg since July 5, and I have lost 2.8 lbs. I have been very true to protocol (one small cheat on day 3), and needless to say I am very frustrated and discouraged. My calories have ranged from 350 to 500 daily.

I hate the idea of quitting in mid-stream, but I had so had my heart set on losing 15 lbs. by August 15 (I teach and that's the day I go back to work). I have been lurking on your threads and it seems like so many of you are having a great deal of success...it doesn't seem any more restrictive than the hcg plan and actually seems like you get more to eat. Has anyone here done the hcg and changed to QWL? Even if you haven't, I would really welcome any thoughts/opinions to help me decide...is it possible to lose 10 - 15 lbs in a month?

Thanks so much for any advice!

Mar922 07-20-2011 07:50 AM

I haven't done HCG so I can't comment on that but you could easily lose 15 pounds by August 15th if you stick to plan and I think you would probably get to eat more than 350-500 cals a day if its low fat meat you can eat it and the longer you are on plan the less you will eat like right now I am eating tons of chicken (up to 6 breasts a day) but I know once I get into it it will go down to about 2.

6 is alot of protein and expensive but I am lazy so I just eat chicken you can eat much more than that haha

doxielove 07-20-2011 09:25 AM

Thanks for you reply! We are the same height and my weight isn't too far off from your starting weight (I'm 168). I think I will give it a try...

ssabrina 07-21-2011 06:53 PM

I did Stillman's for a week or so, then switched to the HCG diet in June. I didn't feel the weight loss was fast. I gained a ton on the load days, then the scale just crawled once I re-lost the load gain. I was very disappointed. A week ago, I switched back to Stillman, this time taking the low calorie approach I had with the HCG diet. I lost 9.6 lbs the first week back on Stillman! I had the genuine HCG product, but I now know that it's a placebo as far as weight loss is concerned (should have researched more before starting).

Kiley2801 07-22-2011 07:39 AM

I did HCG (pharm-grade, not homeopathic) last year, and lost ~20 pounds in 6 weeks. I really liked the diet, but I did it under the care of a clinic, and I just can't afford to do it again. I've tried the homeopathic versions, and I was seriously ready to gnaw my arm off by the 2nd day!!!

Unfortunately, I didn't keep the weight off- but it's totally MY fault. I began over-indulging in too many sweets and carbs around the holidays.

I'm starting (FINALLY- after much talk) Stillman again on Monday, so it will be interesting to compare the weight loss between the 2 plans.

Quote:

I lost 9.6 lbs the first week back on Stillman!
Wow- that is awesome ssabrina! Way to go.

doxielove 07-22-2011 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ssabrina (Post 14847835)
I did Stillman's for a week or so, then switched to the HCG diet in June. I didn't feel the weight loss was fast. I gained a ton on the load days, then the scale just crawled once I re-lost the load gain. I was very disappointed. A week ago, I switched back to Stillman, this time taking the low calorie approach I had with the HCG diet. I lost 9.6 lbs the first week back on Stillman! I had the genuine HCG product, but I now know that it's a placebo as far as weight loss is concerned (should have researched more before starting).

This is my story completely (the HCG part)...I'm starting Stillman's tomorrow and I hope I have the same kind of success that you had! So did you stay with the 500 calories like HCG or did you have a bit more? i'm excited to start - thank nyou!


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 06:06 AM.