Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   Paleolithic & Neanderthin (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/paleolithic-neanderthin/)
-   -   Primal/paleo people....... do you lose weight on this??? (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/paleolithic-neanderthin/812836-primal-paleo-people-do-you-lose-weight.html)

sweetpoison 09-24-2013 07:47 AM

Primal/paleo people....... do you lose weight on this???
 
Just wondering .... I do not see alot of movement on this board. Those of you doing it... do you lose weight on it??? I have been trying to do at least 80/20 Primal with a lower carb twist (primal and not so much paleo since I still have some hard cheese) and I have been losing. Guess I am looking for other success stories in that area. I do feel better eating this way... even with the horrible cold I have had lately. I LOVE to make a big pot of chicken soup (free range organic) with veggis...... never liked soup before... but love this stuff. Although I am in real need of more "primal meat entrees".

I am trying to get HEALTHY as well as drop the weight.... thats why Primal has gotten to be my choice.
Vicki

tashydoll 09-24-2013 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sweetpoison (Post 16617111)
Just wondering .... I do not see alot of movement on this board. Those of you doing it... do you lose weight on it??? I have been trying to do at least 80/20 Primal with a lower carb twist (primal and not so much paleo since I still have some hard cheese) and I have been losing. Guess I am looking for other success stories in that area. I do feel better eating this way... even with the horrible cold I have had lately. I LOVE to make a big pot of chicken soup (free range organic) with veggis...... never liked soup before... but love this stuff. Although I am in real need of more "primal meat entrees".

I am trying to get HEALTHY as well as drop the weight.... thats why Primal has gotten to be my choice.
Vicki

Hi Vicki...I don't think a lot of people post here so I'll help out if I can. I have been primal now for about 3 months and in the first 2 months I lost the last 5kgs (11lbs) that my body had been hanging on to for about 8 months and have finally reached my goal. So in answer to your question, yes, it is possible to lose weight on this.

My previous WOE was Atkins (30g net carbs/day) and I found after nearly 3 years of this WOE I was very lethargic and had no energy reserves at all. I slowly started adding back more good carbs (fruit/veg/seeds) and dropped my fat intake and the last bit of my weight started to shift and I had tonnes of energy. More reading made me realise that I had changed to a primal diet without even knowing.

The way I do primal is still pretty l/c (compared to the standard diet) and I eat approx Fat:55%, Carbs:15%, & Protein:30% with about 1300-1500 cals/day (minus what I do in exercise). It took a bit of tweaking to get it right for my personal needs and I had to monitor my intake for a few weeks until I could see where I was going wrong. I find if my fat intake is too high, I don't lose, if my protein intake is too high, yep you guessed it, I don't lose! Now I don't even have to think about numbers and I can just tell when I need to eat more/less of something.

It really depends on what your previous WOE was as to whether you will find primal challenging or not I think. For me, I was already not eating sugar and most grains (issues with gluten) so it was a pretty easy switch and my body loves it.

I hope that helps a little bit. I have posted on here a thread for newbies for ideas, tips, and recipes if you would like to join us (some lovely people from the M&E thread have been popping in). If you are looking for a regular thread, I plan on posting daily if I can...http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/pa...pes-share.html

Hope that helps :)

dazygyrl 09-24-2013 05:59 PM

i have lost very little scale weight but quite a few inches. i don't weigh nor measure. i monitor the mirror and my clothes.

i lift heavy 3 times a week and walk quite a bit.

i don't much care about the scale, clothes are getting baggy so that's good with me.

Key Tones 09-25-2013 11:39 AM

I lost a lot of weight on low carb. I didn't see results from switching to paleo, other than an initial loss on Kwasniewski's Optimal Diet followed by a gain after a while. I can't find satiety by increasing fat. I haven't tried NK with a machine.

I have lost weight using the bland approach advocated by Stephan Guyenet (bland paleo foods) combined with Shangri-La/Seth Roberts to use oil shots (I use MCT oil). These are methods to address leptin resistance. I have more information in the thread in my auto signature.

BigRunner 02-09-2014 05:03 AM

I am losing weight with the paleo approach. Currently doing an 8 week challenge at the Crossfit gym. The focus is currently on getting the protein up. My percentages seemed to have settled around 40P, 30F, 30C. Obviously not real low carb. My carbs come mostly from vegetables including the higher carb winter squashes and some sweet potatoes here and there. Since New Year's Day, have given up diet soda and all artificial sweeteners. I am slowly adapting to black coffee. Along the way, have found that dairy was the cause of my life long acne issues. Even whey powder makes me break out. Currently, trying non-dairy protein powders.

Key Tones 02-09-2014 11:05 AM

I've started nutritional ketosis and am seriously studying just exactly what you are supposed to eat and am finding that a lot of the folks on the board are not eating the recommended non-starchy vegetables and fruit, and found that Volek/Phinney do say to clip the fat back for weight loss and raise it for maintenance.

I am also incorporating what I learned from reading Stephan Guyenet and Seth Roberts. I have finally hit ketosis.

I have linked my threads below - time will tell if I succeed with this experiment.

moonmirror 02-13-2014 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigRunner (Post 16792928)
I am losing weight with the paleo approach. Currently doing an 8 week challenge at the Crossfit gym. The focus is currently on getting the protein up. My percentages seemed to have settled around 40P, 30F, 30C. Obviously not real low carb. My carbs come mostly from vegetables including the higher carb winter squashes and some sweet potatoes here and there. Since New Year's Day, have given up diet soda and all artificial sweeteners. I am slowly adapting to black coffee. Along the way, have found that dairy was the cause of my life long acne issues. Even whey powder makes me break out. Currently, trying non-dairy protein powders.

This is my experience as well! I had no idea (and didn't WANT to have that idea!) that dairy and artificial sweeteners were a problem, but they ARE.

I avoid starchy foods: but if I'm going to cheat or have a bite of something it will be fruit or potatoes, NOT GRAINS.

I find I eat probably half the fat on Paleo that I ate on Atkins, and more vegetable carbohydrates: that change is enjoyable to me, more energy, more weight loss, and I think food tastes better with more vegetables. :)

BigRunner 02-16-2014 04:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moonmirror (Post 16799167)

I find I eat probably half the fat on Paleo that I ate on Atkins, and more vegetable carbohydrates: that change is enjoyable to me, more energy, more weight loss, and I think food tastes better with more vegetables. :)

This is what I am experiencing as well. I was stuck with weight loss for years on Atkins. I eat half the fat as well. I initially was going to fight our trainer on the percentage of fat she was recommending. Then, I figured what the heck. What I have been doing isn't working. Might as well try something new. Also testing out the "resistant starch" I have been reading about as well.

Key Tones 02-18-2014 11:46 AM

I watched an interview by Fat Burning Man of Denise Minger. My paleo book club is going to read her book, so I ordered it, which caused me to want to watch the video.

She did make some comments about women having trouble losing weight on paleo. She seems to suggest (she isn't sure) that using more plant-based foods would be helpful for hormonal reasons. I think this is true.

I'm experimenting with MCT oil (again) and it is working. This instead of butter, wild-caught salmon and shellfish instead of beef/chicken, almond milk or coconut milk instead of greek yogurt, using the blender to get the greens down that I can't stand to eat anymore - I've been doing this based on past experience or recent studies, and I think the answer is in here.

I am posting in my thread below that ends with "Roberts" and "Volek" if you are interested.

sagemindworks 02-25-2014 08:48 PM

My wife and I eat a somewhat modified Paleo diet. We eat no grains, dairy or sugar products. She cooks with ghee or lard and we are doing well.

One of the problems we ran into is eating too many nuts and some other things like fruit. We cut them down quite a bit and the weight started coming off.

We, also, don't exercise except for walking daily.

I have lost 60 lbs so far and will continue.

sweetpoison 02-26-2014 03:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Key Tones (Post 16804856)
I watched an interview by Fat Burning Man of Denise Minger. My paleo book club is going to read her book, so I ordered it, which caused me to want to watch the video.

She did make some comments about women having trouble losing weight on paleo. She seems to suggest (she isn't sure) that using more plant-based foods would be helpful for hormonal reasons. I think this is true.

I'm experimenting with MCT oil (again) and it is working. This instead of butter, wild-caught salmon and shellfish instead of beef/chicken, almond milk or coconut milk instead of greek yogurt, using the blender to get the greens down that I can't stand to eat anymore - I've been doing this based on past experience or recent studies, and I think the answer is in here.

I am posting in my thread below that ends with "Roberts" and "Volek" if you are interested.

Tell me... does MCT oil have a taste...... sounds like a good idea... but I like my butter for the taste.

Key Tones 02-26-2014 05:12 PM

No, it tastes like nothing, really.

Katy 02-28-2014 10:38 AM

I've started doing primal about a week ago after 2 months of no loss on Atkins/vlc. I'm finally seeing a little bit of weight loss and I feel better. People kept telling me to lower my carbs to see results but it was not working well for me. I even tried the atkins fat fast and all it did was make me crave a salad. We'll see how this goes.

Sicca 02-28-2014 11:24 AM

I'm going for a Paleo challenge the entire month of March!! My goal is not to lose weight because I"m at my goal weight currently and just maintaining. BUT I do hope it can help me knock the artificial crap out of my diet and cut back on all the dairy.

Katy 03-01-2014 12:48 PM

I weighed myself today and am down 6 pounds in just under a week doing primal. This is after 3 months doing vlc 25 g or less a day and losing 2 pounds. I'm now eating around 50g of carbs a day. I feel so good.

vuittonobsessed 03-03-2014 09:51 AM

I've actually been on Paleo lifestyle for a little over a year. I started out at 219 (I'm 5'9 and was a size 16 at the time). I've lost a total of 54lbs so far. I'm currently at 165 and between a size 10 and 12. I don't really exercise but I have two young kids that I'm always chasing around (and taking to the park). I have two 10lbs each dumb bells and a 10lbs medicine ball (that I use for squats) that I use maybe 3-4 times a week for like 10 minutes. I'm currently doing strict Paleo (whole30 but I'm doing it for 90 days).

I've done Atkins in the past but wasn't as successful. I love that I can still eat lots of carbs (I probably eat like 100-200 carbs a day) and not gain the fat back.

SlimFast 03-17-2014 09:44 AM

Yes, I lose on Paleo (Primal) but very slowly lately. I lose quicker if I am strict about not having any dairy, starches, or natural sugars. But I only REALLY lose lately if I cut out most of the fat too, and choose leaner meats, removing the visible fat and skin.

If you look at my stats, you'll see a big loss and MOST of that was done just Primal eating. But to lose any more I have now had to step it up a notch.

SpikersMom 04-27-2014 04:30 PM

Hello I consider my diet a mix of LC and primal. I am officially pre-diabetic but consider myself a type II diabetic . All of this hit me last fall. Honestly I ignored it for a while and then got a glucose meter and started testing a lot. I am very sensitive to carbs - like bread and potatoes. My favorite foods of course. I eat eggs, meat, some cheese, berries, soups, and veggies. I know I have to limit my portions all the time. I don't measure or weigh or even keep track of what I eat daily. I seem to know when to stop eating intuitively. It has started clicking for me in the past few weeks. Since February I've lost about ten pounds. It's slow but steady and I'm okay with it. I currently don't exercise but plan to start shortly.

Janknitz 04-27-2014 07:04 PM

I'm a little confused by this question because it seems to imply that low carb and Paleo/Primal are mutually exclusive, and I don't agree with that premise.

I think that Paleo/Primal is about clean eating natural sources of food--grass fed meat, wild caught fish, natural fats, organic veggies, no grains. While Paleo/Primal permit some natural sugars (depending on who you ask) and starchy veggies, there's no REQUIREMENT that you eat them. So it's possible to follow a Paleo/Primal diet while being LC or VLC--even ketogenic. To me, that's the healthiest approach to VLC.

I started out on a VLC, but about the time started to read about Paleo and Primal. I wanted to continue to be VLC but I wanted to do so healthfully, and I realized that AS, industrial seed and nut oils, grain fed meats and conventionally grown veggies were not going to get me there.

So I would answer that yes, you can lose weight on a Paleo or Primal diet, but it may also have to be lower in carbs. About 50 of my 70+ pounds lost have been lost primally AND VLC.

ETA that just going Primal or Paleo may help you lose weight if you come to it from the SAD, because it's a LOT fewer carbs even if you eat starchy vegs, fruit, and natural sugars ad lib. But for sustained weight loss, you may need more--low carb better than low calorie, IMHO.

rachel2writer 04-30-2014 11:57 AM

I started paleo March 17. For the first four weeks, I didn't lose anything, BUT I was feeling so great, I kept going. Now, these past two weeks, I have dropped 6 pounds. I've added 3 times a week bodyweight training, too.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 09:36 PM.