Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   Medi Weightloss (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/medi-weightloss/)
-   -   Does anyone weigh MORE after working out? (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/medi-weightloss/685679-does-anyone-weigh-more-after-working-out.html)

Cshel37 08-03-2010 07:52 AM

Does anyone weigh MORE after working out?
 
I like my exercise class but it has a bad side-effect: I weigh more the next day and a couple of days after that. I have to weigh in tomorrow and I am going to show a 1.5 pound GAIN because I worked out 3 times since my last weigh in. I understand that sore muscles retain water, but come on! I'm not power-lifting or anything. It's just Jazzercise- 40 minutes of aerobics and 20 minutes of really light (like 2 or 3 pound) hand weights, abs and stretching.

Anybody else have this?

:confused:

Dragonfire 08-03-2010 08:02 AM

That happens to me too! Whenever I work out, I always weigh 2 sometimes 3 times more. Then if I give myself a 2 day break, all that water goes plus whatever the lbs lost.

It is super frustrating but your stats are great so keep doing what you're doing and make sure you drink lots of water.

Ortal 08-03-2010 08:07 AM

whoa whoa whoa, back up, i JUST made a post like this in the august thread *goes to find it*


Quote:

The scale however... I am eating about 800 cals a day, burning a conservative 300-400 cals in my workouts, and the scale is registering gains. Im considering the fact that I may be retaining water, because i KNOW its not a calorie issue, but its frustrating. I know when I did weight watchers, if i didn't work out the day before my weigh in I would loose more. Why is that? I don't want to play those scale games this time around and time my workouts around weigh ins, but its tough when you pay 70$ a week, you want to see results.

I feel your frustration. I know muscles retain more water after a workout, I just would have hoped that the next morning I still wouldnt be up so much.

Cshel37 08-03-2010 08:16 AM

It's sooo not fair. I'm like a giant sponge. I gain water weight if someone even mentions water retention (see, I think I just gained another pound).

Desert-Rose7 08-03-2010 10:06 AM

There is a thread for exercise, not sure what all is in there anymore but it might be a great place for questions like this:

http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/me...xercisers.html

Do make sure that you are drinking all your water too. Drinking water before, during, and after exercise. And stretching out before and after exercise to help your muscles and tendons recuperate. It is frustrating nonetheless, but keep on keeping on. Try not to weigh yourself so many times a day....you will drive yourself nuts.

In the acute phase, ideally, weigh only at the clinic on your appointment days.

Jo

onajourney 08-03-2010 04:43 PM

I am glad to see others have the same issue, I thought it was just me.
I know muscles retain water but I had not heard many people mention or talk about how it effects their weigh in.
The weeks I didnt work out a day or 2 before my weigh-in I did a lot better. I do easily retain water.
I always drink my water but I still retain after working out.

Thank You for sharing it really helps.

Charlene4 08-03-2010 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Desert-Rose7 (Post 13755664)
There is a thread for exercise, not sure what all is in there anymore but it might be a great place for questions like this:

http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/me...xercisers.html

Do make sure that you are drinking all your water too. Drinking water before, during, and after exercise. And stretching out before and after exercise to help your muscles and tendons recuperate. It is frustrating nonetheless, but keep on keeping on. Try not to weigh yourself so many times a day....you will drive yourself nuts.

In the acute phase, ideally, weigh only at the clinic on your appointment days.

Jo


I agree that you will make yourself crazy if you weight more often. I am tempted sometimes but try to resist. The only time I normally weigh on my own scale is the day after my weigh in, to see how my scale compares. I have only weighed about 2 times that weren't right after a clinic weigh in. I like the surprise of seeing what I have lost. I have thought about this water retention thing too and I believe that what everyone is saying seems correct. I actually gained a couple pounds of water at my last weigh in. I lost a pound of fat though. I think this might have to do with two things: 1)I have stepped up my workouts to at least 6 days a week and more intensity, plus light weights 2) a combo of not getting the mid week injection and eating a little more sodium than I should. I seem to be having this recurring bloating issue that has worsened in the last week or so....:confused:

SonoRoo 08-07-2010 05:15 AM

This is SO timely!!! I lost 4.4 lbs in fat last week but was up over 5 lbs in water. My total loss was only 0.8 lbs but a loss none the less. What I am frustrated about is the fact that I am exercising and drinking all my water and I am still retaining water!!! I am swollen and can feel it in my hands. I really want to make it into the 150's this week before my Thursday weigh in. I think some of it has to do with muscle fatigue from slacking off the last few weeks and then exercising this week, but I am getting seriously frustrated at this point. Instead of Advil for the musle pain I took a Midol that has the mild diuretic in it just to reduce some of the swelling. My massage therapist is coming to the house today so I am praying she will work out some of the musle kinks that may be causing me to retain water. I should be able to tell by Sunday morning.

GirlInJersey 08-09-2010 10:52 AM

People think I'm crazy when I say I don't lose as much on the weeks I work out hard. I have been running a lot lately and my weight this week seems to have gone UP! So annoying. So I'm taking today off and hope that my weigh in tomorrow goes well and all balances out.

Jeffrey 08-13-2010 06:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GirlInJersey (Post 13774762)
People think I'm crazy when I say I don't lose as much on the weeks I work out hard. I have been running a lot lately and my weight this week seems to have gone UP! So annoying. So I'm taking today off and hope that my weigh in tomorrow goes well and all balances out.

When you workout hard you may be gaining muscle mass which could account for a low weight loss or slight gain. Are your clinics going over fat mass and muscle mass losses/gains with you? I think those are vital to be encouraged and to see that your hard work really is paying off, even if the scale doesn't seem to agree.

--------------- And regarding any weight gain just after a workout, this is likely due to any water or electrolyte drinks you may have during or right after a workout. It seems like if you didn't drink anything you should lose a little bit of weight from sweat.

Ortal 08-19-2010 05:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeffrey (Post 13787172)
When you workout hard you may be gaining muscle mass which could account for a low weight loss or slight gain. Are your clinics going over fat mass and muscle mass losses/gains with you? I think those are vital to be encouraged and to see that your hard work really is paying off, even if the scale doesn't seem to agree.

--------------- And regarding any weight gain just after a workout, this is likely due to any water or electrolyte drinks you may have during or right after a workout. It seems like if you didn't drink anything you should lose a little bit of weight from sweat.

your muscles retain more water too after a workout, which can linger for a day or two. not just what you actually drink/pee out


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:25 PM.