Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   Main Lowcarb Lobby (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/main-lowcarb-lobby/)
-   -   Anyone done the Blood Type Diet? (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/main-lowcarb-lobby/799212-anyone-done-blood-type-diet.html)

Bamboozled 03-11-2013 11:03 AM

Anyone done the Blood Type Diet?
 
Interested to know if anyone found success with a diet specifically tailored for their blood type.

Of course I don't think this diet is the be all end all but I'm interested to try as my success with low carb has stopped and I've been having stomach and heart problems.

My blood type is O+. I've been thinking my issues are with cheese so when I read that O+ are not supposed to eat dairy, I was interested. I have an autoimmune disease that I am managing without meds and a big part of that was cutting out milk. I've never had a problem with cheese until now.


Anyways- anyone else tried this? Did it help or no?

Ntombi 03-11-2013 11:33 AM

I never have, and I think it's hooey.

LoriAS 03-11-2013 11:40 AM

My sister-in-law is doing this and having some moderate success. I really can't speak to specifics though.

Sharss 03-11-2013 01:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bamboozled (Post 16309466)
Interested to know if anyone found success with a diet specifically tailored for their blood type.

Of course I don't think this diet is the be all end all but I'm interested to try as my success with low carb has stopped and I've been having stomach and heart problems.

My blood type is O+. I've been thinking my issues are with cheese so when I read that O+ are not supposed to eat dairy, I was interested. I have an autoimmune disease that I am managing without meds and a big part of that was cutting out milk. I've never had a problem with cheese until now.


Anyways- anyone else tried this? Did it help or no?

What's the name of the book, Bam? I've heard of it, but never read it. Would love to see if the library has it. I've never done that diet, but would be interested in reading what it says as I know my bod does best with protein. Problem now for me is that it's been so long since I had my blood tested, I don't have a clue what I am and I simply don't remember.

____________________________
Keep your eye on YOUR goal and you'll way more easily navigate around the discouraging obstacles.
___________________________

KEEP MOVING FORWARD
Sharon
:heart:

tobelowcarber 03-11-2013 01:49 PM

I have been on it for over 12 years and it is amazing.

tobelowcarber 03-11-2013 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sharss (Post 16309734)
What's the name of the book, Bam? I've heard of it, but never read it. Would love to see if the library has it. I've never done that diet, but would be interested in reading what it says as I know my bod does best with protein. Problem now for me is that it's been so long since I had my blood tested, I don't have a clue what I am and I simply don't remember.

____________________________
Keep your eye on YOUR goal and you'll way more easily navigate around the discouraging obstacles.
___________________________

KEEP MOVING FORWARD
Sharon
:heart:

"Eat Right for Your Type" Dr Peter D'Adamo. The author has a very informative website.

Sharss 03-11-2013 04:12 PM

Thank you so much, tobelowcarber! :up:

JUst looked and my library DOES have the book! :cool: I've always been so curious about it.

____________________________
Keep your eye on YOUR goal and you'll way more easily navigate around the discouraging obstacles.
___________________________

KEEP MOVING FORWARD
Sharon
:heart:

lterry913 03-11-2013 04:17 PM

I don't know anyone doing this but I do know a few doing the Body Type diet...based on how your body carries excess weight...they are always hungry when I see them and cheating often because of it. They even bum food off me cause my stuff is so good...they should just switch teams and suffer no more haha.

snowmop 03-11-2013 05:39 PM

According to him, I would do well as a vegetarian. I'll stick to high fat meats, thanks.

Ntombi 03-11-2013 05:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tobelowcarber (Post 16309798)
I have been on it for over 12 years and it is amazing.

Your stats say you're doing JUDDD and Atkins. Are you doing all three? How does that work?

Gretalyn 03-11-2013 07:17 PM

I tried it, and it was the single worst diet I've ever done in my life, and I've done quite a few. I kid you not, I was in far worse health doing that than when I was just eating the standard American high-sugar, processed junk food diet.

But I am a type A, and my strong impression is that type O's do pretty well on his diet (not coincidence, I think, that his type O diet is the one that is closest to Atkins and other low carb plans!). His type A diet is complete and utter crap. It is so bad that I concluded (after suffering from mineral deficiencies and hormonal problems) that his whole theory is also crap. So I would recommend that you simply try a really well formulated low-carb or paleo plan instead.

I'm sorry if I sound too blunt. I'm normally a nice person, I promise! :D

Liz1959 03-11-2013 07:28 PM

I got it from the library several years ago. I don't think I read the book. I copied my, type O, lists out of it and stuck them in with my cookbooks. Never looked at them again until now.
It's kind of amusing. I should avoid all pork, but beef is beneficial.
Beneficial pastas, grains and cereals = None
Brussel sprouts, cabbage, and cauliflower are on my AVOID list... not happening!

jazills 03-11-2013 10:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bamboozled (Post 16309466)

My blood type is O+. I've been thinking my issues are with cheese so when I read that O+ are not supposed to eat dairy, I was interested. I have an autoimmune disease that I am managing without meds and a big part of that was cutting out milk. I've never had a problem with cheese until now.


Anyways- anyone else tried this? Did it help or no?

INTERESTING, but it makes perfect sense. I am O+ and seriously have major issues with cheese and weight loss. Dairy in general actually. I want to cut out dairy but it's so darn hard!!!

biancasteeplechase 03-12-2013 06:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ntombi (Post 16309520)
I never have, and I think it's hooey.

Yeah, it's based on a claim that blood types evolved much, much later than we know they did. There's never been a study on it.

Your blood type doesn't play a role in how you digest carbohydrates - so why would it determine whether you'd be better off on a high-carb or low-carb diet?

One doctor who spent his life studying blood and nutrition called the diet "horse manure".

raindroproses 03-12-2013 12:50 PM

Huh, I'd never heard of it but when I checked out the doctor's website... he actually got a LOT of things right about me (I'm type O-). I do have low thyroid, and insulin resistance, and he was spot on about how I handle stress and other things like that. Whether those were just lucky guesses or not, I have no idea. I might buy into the fact that your blood type can make you more susceptible to certain illnesses or weaknesses. But I wouldn't change my diet over it. I'm happy and healthy where I am :)

avid 03-12-2013 03:03 PM

I think this diet proves that if you follow ANY diet faithfully it will work.
I mean think about it.....the typical American diet is so carb loaded and generally horrible that it doesn't take much to vastly improve on it.

synger 03-12-2013 03:46 PM

I do a modified blood type/body type diet. It's called low-carb. Fortunately, that's the diet that works best for my type!

Sharss 03-12-2013 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Liz1959 (Post 16310522)
I got it from the library several years ago. I don't think I read the book. I copied my, type O, lists out of it and stuck them in with my cookbooks. Never looked at them again until now.
It's kind of amusing. I should avoid all pork, but beef is beneficial.
Beneficial pastas, grains and cereals = None
Brussel sprouts, cabbage, and cauliflower are on my AVOID list... not happening!

:rofl::rofl: I must be an O. I hate Brussel sprouts, cauliflower, but will eat cabbage.

I called my ex to find out what his blood type was as he's had serious surgery a few years ago. Last time I had my blood typed was when we were married (1960). I remembered one of us was an O and one of us an A. He has to call one of his doctors to find out which he is - then I'll know mine. :laugh:

Many must be interested in this book. If I read correctly there are 59 library holds on it. Maybe next year? :D

____________________________
Keep your eye on YOUR goal and you'll way more easily navigate around the discouraging obstacles.
___________________________

KEEP MOVING FORWARD
Sharon
:heart:

Bamboozled 03-18-2013 08:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jazills (Post 16310713)
INTERESTING, but it makes perfect sense. I am O+ and seriously have major issues with cheese and weight loss. Dairy in general actually. I want to cut out dairy but it's so darn hard!!!


Me too! I cannot tolerate milk at all but when I tested cheese (elimination diet) I was fine. Well that is NOT the case as I now know that I really cannot tolerate cheese. It sucks because what is better than cheese!

So no cheese, no cauli or cabbage, no mushrooms, etc. Adding carrots back in to my diet. Cutting out pork as well. Basically it is a "healthier" low carb. No processed meats, no bacon, ham. I'm really hoping to restart my weight loss with this as I have been stalled for months.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gretalyn (Post 16310494)
I tried it, and it was the single worst diet I've ever done in my life, and I've done quite a few. I kid you not, I was in far worse health doing that than when I was just eating the standard American high-sugar, processed junk food diet.

But I am a type A, and my strong impression is that type O's do pretty well on his diet (not coincidence, I think, that his type O diet is the one that is closest to Atkins and other low carb plans!). His type A diet is complete and utter crap. It is so bad that I concluded (after suffering from mineral deficiencies and hormonal problems) that his whole theory is also crap. So I would recommend that you simply try a really well formulated low-carb or paleo plan instead.

I'm sorry if I sound too blunt. I'm normally a nice person, I promise! :D

My friend is type A.. I mentioned this diet to her and she was horrified at what it wanted her to eat. Honestly? If the recommended diet was anything other than what it is (type O+) I wouldn't be doing it! But the restrictions it makes makes sense to me. I know I need to cut out dairy and I have wondered for a long time if it might be farting with my thyroid function. It even said that dairy can cause cardiac problems for type O's and I have been having chest pains for awhile now.

I'm eager to try it but of course very skeptical! Just like you said, it's a good WOE because it is low carb. I know low carb works for me but I also know that dairy isn't. I can live without the other veggies it restricts, it's not a huge deal. Will just take some getting used to.

Bamboozled 03-18-2013 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by avid (Post 16312279)
I think this diet proves that if you follow ANY diet faithfully it will work.
I mean think about it.....the typical American diet is so carb loaded and generally horrible that it doesn't take much to vastly improve on it.

This is why I am very interested to see my results on it.

I have been low carb since September and have done it for years on and off. I know what my success has been. By trimming down my diet yet again I can see if this diet really does work best for me.

A lot of the things Dr Adamo has to say about O+ ring true with me. Reading the other diet types, nope, not so much.

Gretalyn 03-18-2013 09:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bamboozled (Post 16322209)
My friend is type A.. I mentioned this diet to her and she was horrified at what it wanted her to eat. Honestly? If the recommended diet was anything other than what it is (type O+) I wouldn't be doing it! But the restrictions it makes makes sense to me. I know I need to cut out dairy and I have wondered for a long time if it might be farting with my thyroid function. It even said that dairy can cause cardiac problems for type O's and I have been having chest pains for awhile now.

I'm eager to try it but of course very skeptical! Just like you said, it's a good WOE because it is low carb. I know low carb works for me but I also know that dairy isn't. I can live without the other veggies it restricts, it's not a huge deal. Will just take some getting used to.

I can understand wanting to try it under your circumstances. Good luck, and just listen to your body and I bet you'll do fine.

Bamboozled 03-20-2013 08:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gretalyn (Post 16322326)
I can understand wanting to try it under your circumstances. Good luck, and just listen to your body and I bet you'll do fine.

Thank you!

Funny enough, today it hit me that I am absolutely doing South Beach Phase 2 right now! The additions I've made to my diet put me in Phase 2. I've been meaning to move on to phase 2 so I thought that was kind of neat!

Going to start eating a bit of brown rice, fruits, etc. All in moderation of course.

I've lost 3lbs in 2 days!! Feels good. Wasn't expecting that.

jemmi 09-07-2013 03:33 PM

I started the Blood Type food plan for O's (and I'm a secretor*), and in one month now, I lost 10.5 lbs.

*To be a secretor means that I secrete my blood type antigen into my saliva, which most people do. For those that do not, and are referred to as "non-secretors," they will face certain health issues, and have to be a bit more careful, and some of the foods they can or cannot eat are different from a secretor.

I have more energy, sleep better, and I don't have any food cravings.

Once more of my health issues have resolved, and I've lost more weight, then I will introduce more neutral foods. As much as possible, I stay away from all AVOID foods.

For anyone wanting to lose weight, one should eat mainly Beneficial, Highly-Beneficial, and Super-Beneficial foods for their blood type. (The Highly-Beneficial and Super-Beneficial foods are those that help with cancer and diabetes.)

I do not think it fair that some of you say it is "theory," or saying it's just something Dr. D'Adamo makes "claims" about. Why not read the book and see that there has been years upon years of scientific study, started by his father. The science continues today. It can be viewed under a microscope what happens to your blood cells before and after you eat something not good for your blood type. The cells clump together, and so on; and it is that clumping that eventually can lead to health problems.

Some said they tried it, and didn't feel well. Have you considered that your body was now ridding itself of the toxins from the unacceptable foods, and the "housecleaning" made you sick? You have to give your organs time to "take out the trash." Before you begin, become informed about the steps, and what to expect, just like you would do if you were starting the low-carb plan. I mean, doing this is for YOUR benefit. Then you can almost look forward to having some days when you feel yucky, knowing that the body, in all its wisdom, wants to get well, lose the excess weight, and re-balance itself.

Please don't just toss out unfavorable words so that you can feel better about the food plan you have chosen. It's fine for you to select whichever one you wish, but when you do not speak from a place of knowledge, then your words are empty; but even worse, you could discourage someone who might really benefit from the Blood Type food plan. :( :sad:

Those of you who love and defend Dr. Atkins, do you like it when people say his program is nonsense, or he died, not from a head injury, but because he was fat and had heart disease from eating from his own food plan?

I have great respect for Dr. Atkins, and I did his program for years, but only had partial success, and my health was not improving. Now I know that I cannot tolerate dairy, except butter, ghee, and mozzarella cheese. And that when I eat beef, it should only be grass-fed.

I still make the 3-minute flourless cake (from Atkins plan), or when I double the recipe, it becomes a 5-minute cake. I use the same recipe to make pancakes. I make it with and without the cocoa powder, so that it can be a morning muffin, or dessert cake. Sometimes I add walnuts, blueberries, or strawberries. Yum! I just don't eat it with whipped cream anymore.

I have a peanut butter cookie recipe on here, but now I know that I can't eat peanut butter, because of the fungus and mold found in peanut butter. Do I miss peanut butter? Yes. :cry: Has almond butter taken its place? No. I eat almond butter, but nothing replaces peanut butter. C'mon! :laugh: But I do not eat it anymore because I'd rather get well, and lose weight. :up: :clap:

We all make our own choices, as it should be, but give space and respect for whatever food plan is out there, and there are plenty! This one is definitely helping me, and I appreciate that!

If you are interested to find out if it could also work for you, then I encourage you to try it. The library has the books for free, and recipes can be found online, or in his books; and focus on the best foods for your blood type. Then you can make the decision for yourself, based on your own experience.

Take care!

Aomiel 09-07-2013 04:09 PM

I have read his book and the 'science' just doesn't back him. To be honest, when I read his book, I wanted to believe him but he tends to make statements that are hard to ignore. According to him, my blood type...

...tended to have a greater ability to adapt to altitude and interestingly, are statistically the tallest of the blood types.

Not so much. I am 5'3" and have a serious problem with altitudes (migraines, bloody noses, nausea, etc.). We have a lot of this blood type in our family and we're all considered shorter than average (men and women).


Go to bed no later than 11:00PM and sleep for eight hours or more. It is essential to maintain their circadian rhythm


If I stay up later than 10 p.m., I become a twitching, nervous wreck.

Engage in a community, neighborhood or other group activity that gives you a meaningful connection to a group. Natural born networkers

Definitely not. I avoid groups like the plague and am happiest when I'm by myself. I tend to rub people the wrong way because I'm fairly blunt (try to be tactful) but don't play social games.

As they age, they have a tendency to suffer memory loss and have decreased mental acuity.

I'm only 57 so have no personal experience, but my mom, her mom and several aunts (all in their 70's-90's) have my blood type and they are as sharp as tacks. I *wish* they suffered some memory loss sometimes as life might be more pleasant. :D

As much as I 'wanted' to believe he had a very real theory, I kind of felt like I was reading a book of horoscopes.

If his diet worked for you, then kudos...but I just don't buy the 'science' behind it.

Aomiel 09-07-2013 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by avid (Post 16312279)
I think this diet proves that if you follow ANY diet faithfully it will work.
I mean think about it.....the typical American diet is so carb loaded and generally horrible that it doesn't take much to vastly improve on it.


:goodpost:

Natalia 09-08-2013 05:43 AM

I think it's more like the people having success on this diet are O's.
The majority are O.
The O plan closely resembles Atkins.
That's it.

I'm B+. I wonder what I should eat? Lol

jemmi 09-08-2013 07:45 AM

Aomiel, what you spoke of has nothing to do with the science of how foods affect our health, internally, and externally.

What you mention sounds more like observations, and generalizations.

When I read the book by Dr. Abravanel about Body Types, he had observations and generalizations like that as well. And just like you, many did not fit me either.

I'm a Thyroid body type, but they were described more like the tall, lean Greyhounds, but I'm only 5'3". I do not have long slender hands/fingers, but they are also not short and pudgy...they are just normal (for me) hands.

You can be more than one body type, so I'm a dominant Thyroid, with secondary being Gonadal (ovaries). Body types are readily identified when people are overweight. The shape of the body is so classic that you can't mistake it. For women, there are 4 types, and for men, 3 types (because men do not have ovaries). Everyone has a dominant gland, and that is what dictates where your body will store fat, factored on that dominant gland.

I digress from Dr. D'Adamo, but as you can see, it is and can be helpful to learn about many approaches to good health and weight loss. Having more information tucked under your belt is a good thing.

Look online for how to determine your metabolic type as well. For all three, Blood Type, Metabolic Type, and Body Type, I am a person that needs protein, and yes, I did okay on the Atkins plan, except the dairy didn't do me any favors, and while I miss heavy whipping cream, and many of the cheeses in the dairy line, I've had no problem at all letting them go, because I feel well on the Blood Type food plan.

jemmi 09-08-2013 08:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Natalia (Post 16594949)
I think it's more like the people having success on this diet are O's.
The majority are O.
The O plan closely resembles Atkins.
That's it.

I'm B+. I wonder what I should eat? Lol

Well, if you prefer to do Dr. Atkins, but would like to have a bit of an edge (in a good way), then do the Dr. Atkins food plan, but because you are Blood Type B (same as my brother), AVOID chicken, lobster, and shrimp (just to name a few), because chicken causes your blood cells to clump together (agglutination), and lobster and shrimp have a few things going on that are not so good for you, and one of them is what is called the "Indican" level.

Indican is formed by an abnormal metabolism of tryptophan. It's a by-product of putrefaction (protein degradation), usually in the intestine, but possibly in other locations as well. Putrefaction is the anaerobic bacterial decomposition of proteins - so it's not the ideal, nor healthy way for your body to deal with proteins.

But the excellent meats for you are goat, lamb, and mutton. Why? because they are nutrient dense foods (Dr. Oz, Dr. Joel Fuhrman, and Dr. Mark Hyman all speak of nutrient dense foods which give you more bang for your buck). And some of the best fish is Cod, and Salmon. Cod is helpful if you have cancer or diabetes, and salmon is helpful if you have cancer.

Dairy: Cottage cheese is great for you! Why? Because it provides optimal amino acid (lysine/arginine) ratio. Goat cheese too!

That's a sampling. If you want more foods, just ask. But you see that you can do Dr. Atkins if that is what you prefer, only tweak it a bit for your blood type.

At the beginning of one of his books, Dr. D'Adamo speaks of seeing a Rabbi who was a B. His health had declined and he had trouble walking (or may have become bedridden). I haven't read the true story in many years, but Jewish people are big on chicken, which is fine, but not for him. Long story short, his foods were tweaked, avoid this food, instead, eat this, etc. In a few short weeks, the Rabbi felt improvement, and was able to walk better and even was able to play with his grandson. I'm not saying he had abundant health restored in those few weeks, but I'm saying it was enough to effect a change that was evident to everyone in his family, including himself.

Try it. Maybe you'll like it. :D

tobelowcarber 09-08-2013 08:29 AM

Jemmi- hello to another BTDieter. I am B non-secretor. I have been on "diet" for 12 years. You are lucky to be a secretor. I am in the minority of the population.

You wont find much support here for the BTD. I don't feel like defending the diet anymore. I know it works for me and my family and friends. People think of it as a weight loss diet. It will make you lose weight as "side effect" but you do it for health benefits. There is a lot of criticism of the diet on the net from people who did not do the research. There is huge following with people who got amazing health benefits. Dr D'Adamo message board is very active with members from around the world. The book has been translated into many languages and his has written many more books. There is a lot research that went in to it, many many years and in fact it is an ongoing research. His latest book-Genotype Diet combines blood type diet with your genotype. He is a brilliant researcher!!!

The diet has helped me tremendously with various health issues. I am so blessed to have found it. My friend with severe psoriasis and high blood pressure has no issues after few month of changing her diet. My other friend who was always skinny and thinking he was eating healthy by eating chicken and lentils and veggies every day developed diabetes in his mid 50s (he is a B type and chicken and lentils are big time no no food for B type). He used to discount the BTD when I told him about it many years ago. Anyhow, after the diagnosis he called me and said he is ready to give a try. Guess what? his diabetes is gone after few month, much to his doctors surprise!

Natalia 09-08-2013 08:44 AM

Jemmi- thank you for taking the time to give me a brief overview of my blood type.
I see now that LC and eating for your blood type are not mutually exclusive.
But, you lost me at lobster ! I love it so much.. But don't eat it often.

Marika- I sense your frustration. You're right- most people here have found their way and a blood type plan is not what they're looking for.

Honestly? Yes, it sounds hokey on the surface. But so did Atkins at first!
Doesn't mean it can't be useful.

Even if you guys get a largely negative response here, I don't think anyone would begrudge someone doing the best for them. I am very happy you both found your way and are thriving on this plan.

I may just look into it, for curiosity's sake.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:53 PM.