Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   JUDDD (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/)
-   -   Weight Watchers vs JUDDD (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/815979-weight-watchers-vs-juddd.html)

MintQ8 10-25-2013 11:19 AM

Weight Watchers vs JUDDD
 
Not to diss WW (I've followed it successfully in the past) but on a beach picnic today, I enjoyed a great UD - my lovely friend following WW - ate a little more than 'allowed' and her diet was bust for the day - so she was going to restart tomorrow.

Now there are DD that don't always work, some UUAAD but you never feel like the diet is blown . . .

Love JUDDD.

LoCarbGal 10-25-2013 11:35 AM

I totally agree Vicky! I tried WW many years ago and was always hungry and unsatisfied, and the results weren't that great either. I know my slant is mostly due to a very disagreeable (almost abusive) group leader too.

I will always love and be indebted to Atkins, but it's the same thing there. Once you're in ketosis, if you stray even just a little, it can take you days to get back into it.

JUDDD is ever flexible, and never wags it's finger at you for the next 3 days!

Sunshinegirl44 10-25-2013 12:45 PM

:goodpost: I agree with you both :high5: I believe this is the only WOE that will get me to my goal. The weight may not come off as fast as some of the other quick weight loss diets I have been on, but I just wind up gaining back what I have lost with those :stars: It may be slower but it sure is steady. Best of all no guilt involved :console: I just feel normal :) I have been keeping it real simple on my DD. I have one snickers at lunch and one snickers at dinner which equals out to an even 500 calories and my stomach is so shrunk on my UD I am not even hungry and it doesn't take much to satisfy me. So no counting calories at all so far for me :lol: When I am at my goal, I will go to the 5:2 to maintain.

MintQ8 10-25-2013 12:50 PM

I'm afraid to say I love the idea of snickers for my down day meals!

Barbo 10-25-2013 12:56 PM

I can agree with that statement
 
regarding WW blow out.

Today is my down day and tomorrow is my medium day.
However, that is not going to work with my social Friday today.
Not to fear on JUDDD. I am making today my medium day and
tomorrow will be the DD. I don't feel that this is cheating on this
program. Life brings you situations unexpected day by day and
on JUDDD you can roll with it.

mojocat 10-25-2013 12:56 PM

As a maintainer I'm find I gravitate towards a natural JUDDD way of eating. If I eat too much one day, I seem to require less the next day and almost do an intuitive type of JUDDD at around 500 cals on the lower days. This seems to be working and I'm pretty happy atm. Not stressing too much if I overeat. Seems to be a better way than counting and tracking my maintenance calories every day.

Carol an abusive type leader? That's awful. Reminds me of a british comedy show called Little Britain on telly where one of the regular characters is an abusive bully type leader of a weight group....

LoCarbGal 10-25-2013 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintQ8 (Post 16658239)
I'm afraid to say I love the idea of snickers for my down day meals!

Me too! Too bad I'm on my no-sugar plan right now. Maybe after Halloween I'll try that!

I've also been tempted to try a wine (or gimlet) DD. It works for Kissa!

KeirasMom 10-25-2013 02:32 PM

Now why didn't I think of a Snickers DD? Maybe a Snickers for lunch and a large rum/cascade ice coconut for dinner?

Babsbabs 10-25-2013 04:41 PM

I don't miss all the negative feelings I used to battle with on other plans when I gave up and ate foods not allowed on whatever plan I was following. Constantly trying to resist eating high carb or high calorie foods usually landed me in front of the tv with those items eventually and then it would take weeks to get back my motivation back to start dieting again. :heart:JUDDD! Great reminder Vicky!

Carly 10-25-2013 04:56 PM

I can't imagine a day where I no longer love JUDDD. It doesn't matter to me if I'm doing EOD rotations, 4:3 or 5:2. I love how I feel and how easy it is to maintain my weight.

Beeb 10-25-2013 04:58 PM

Just to give the other side of this:

I did JUDDD VERY successfully, as many of you know, and if not for an eating issue triggered by this WOE I would still be doing JUDDD but......I will say that doing the new WW Points Plus plan I am still eating everything I want and actually eating so much better than I have on any other plan AND those eating issues that came about are now 99% gone!! PLUS being able to eat an apple or banana, which are 0 points, and not blowing my calories or points for the day, is very freeing, let me tell you! The fact that I have 49 extra points (7 extra a day) to spend as I see fit when needed sure helps me not feel restricted anymore.

As in my JUDDD UDs and DDs, it was always all in the planning. The same with WWs. I go out EVERY SINGLE weekend and eat the way I want to and still continue to lose. I would have to guess your friend didn't plan very well for her dinner out with you. Even on JUDDD it's suggested you have a calorie limit for you UDs and that can be blown just as fast as points are.

So different strokes for different folks and we all need to find the plan that fits us and we can live with as a WOE for life, whatever it is!

Babsbabs 10-25-2013 05:14 PM

I am so happy Linda that you found a plan that is working for you too! Steady calorie restriction made me tired, cold and I wasn't losing weight so led to binging weekends as I just couldn't stay motivated. Your posts on the JUDDD threads convinced me to give this a try and I will always be grateful for the information you passed on. Glad you are still providing information and alternatives for those that need to try a different approach as well. :up:

Librarygirl 10-25-2013 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunshinegirl44 (Post 16658231)
:goodpost: I agree with you both :high5: I believe this is the only WOE that will get me to my goal. The weight may not come off as fast as some of the other quick weight loss diets I have been on, but I just wind up gaining back what I have lost with those :stars: It may be slower but it sure is steady. Best of all no guilt involved :console: I just feel normal :) I have been keeping it real simple on my DD. I have one snickers at lunch and one snickers at dinner which equals out to an even 500 calories and my stomach is so shrunk on my UD I am not even hungry and it doesn't take much to satisfy me. So no counting calories at all so far for me :lol: When I am at my goal, I will go to the 5:2 to maintain.

:eek::lol: You do NOT do that!!! :D :D :D :high5: I see a fellow sugar addict at meetings with me in the future.:cool:

Librarygirl 10-25-2013 06:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeirasMom (Post 16658365)
Now why didn't I think of a Snickers DD? Maybe a Snickers for lunch and a large rum/cascade ice coconut for dinner?


Flutter, Oh Flutterrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!! Remember when we were thinking of doing a candy hack?!:p:D Too bad I'm swearing off sugar.:cool:

MintQ8 10-26-2013 01:50 AM

Beeb, I think you have it right - a lot of it comes to planning! If you don't plan - it's not going to work. I admit that my DD plans aren't that strict, but that's because I've worked out what works and within the realms - stick to it.

If I had been working WW yesterday, I would have really given thought to how to get the most bang for my buck - whereas my friend didn't bring clever snacks for herself - and ate everyone else's - and they're the killer on any weight loss pan - if you don't plan!

I knew I would find it hard to do the day on a DD, so changed my rotations - called it a free day, and enjoyed it. But, if it had had to be a DD, I could have managed - crudités are my friend!

Sirtain 10-26-2013 06:10 AM

More power to you if it works for you, Sunshine, but I could never do a Snickers day. I would be jonesing for sugar for the next three days. I'm always surprised when I see what some people can 'get away with'. Our bodies really are different. That's why it is great that there is not a one size fits all program. I have had enough of following the conventional wisdom and doing nothing but GAINING weight and still feeling hungry.

On the WW issue- it worked for me several* times, as long as I could stick to it. But I never did. I would get hungry, and also, annoyed with tracking and counting, and fall off. And it was never easy to get back on after a taste of 'freedom'. With JUDDD, it is easy for me to start over after any slips, because ever day is essentially starting over, and I am getting plenty of practice.

*I think the fact that I tried WW several times, is testament that it is just not the plan for me--I always backslid. I am still on my 'first' round of JUDDD, and have lost more weight that I ever have before AND am not tired of or discouraged by the plan at all. I still feel that I could keep on with this forever. I have been JUDDDing for almost 8 months now, so I am definitely past the first flush of a new diet, where one is still enthusiastic. And yet, I still AM enthusiastic! :)

Librarygirl 10-26-2013 08:38 AM

I agree Sirtain. WW did not work for me either. It was the very first diet plan I ever tried, after the initial weight gain. I remember I was 159 at the first weigh in, which was horrible to me (at the time) lol. I managed to get down to 145 and then it was over, and I gained even more. The next time I tried WW, they did a group at work, and the leader would come to campus once a week. I was closer to 180 at the start that time, I think. I never got lower than a few pound less, and promptly gave up. Thank goodness I finally found JUDDD (and now LC). :)

tobelowcarber 10-26-2013 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beeb (Post 16658495)
Just to give the other side of this:

I did JUDDD VERY successfully, as many of you know, and if not for an eating issue triggered by this WOE I would still be doing JUDDD but......I will say that doing the new WW Points Plus plan I am still eating everything I want and actually eating so much better than I have on any other plan AND those eating issues that came about are now 99% gone!! PLUS being able to eat an apple or banana, which are 0 points, and not blowing my calories or points for the day, is very freeing, let me tell you! The fact that I have 49 extra points (7 extra a day) to spend as I see fit when needed sure helps me not feel restricted anymore.

As in my JUDDD UDs and DDs, it was always all in the planning. The same with WWs. I go out EVERY SINGLE weekend and eat the way I want to and still continue to lose. I would have to guess your friend didn't plan very well for her dinner out with you. Even on JUDDD it's suggested you have a calorie limit for you UDs and that can be blown just as fast as points are.

So different strokes for different folks and we all need to find the plan that fits us and we can live with as a WOE for life, whatever it is!

Linda, I am so HAPPY to read that WW is working well for you :clap:

Beeb 10-26-2013 10:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintQ8 (Post 16658755)
Beeb, I think you have it right - a lot of it comes to planning! If you don't plan - it's not going to work. I admit that my DD plans aren't that strict, but that's because I've worked out what works and within the realms - stick to it.

If I had been working WW yesterday, I would have really given thought to how to get the most bang for my buck - whereas my friend didn't bring clever snacks for herself - and ate everyone else's - and they're the killer on any weight loss pan - if you don't plan!

I knew I would find it hard to do the day on a DD, so changed my rotations - called it a free day, and enjoyed it. But, if it had had to be a DD, I could have managed - crudités are my friend!

:goodpost: :hugs:

Beeb 10-26-2013 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tobelowcarber (Post 16658944)
Linda, I am so HAPPY to read that WW is working well for you :clap:

:hugs:

Flutter 10-26-2013 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Librarygirl (Post 16658578)
Flutter, Oh Flutterrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!! Remember when we were thinking of doing a candy hack?!:p:D Too bad I'm swearing off sugar.:cool:

:hyst::heart: Now, LG, why would you think I know anything about candy & rum on a DD? :faint:

Seriously, though, there is no other plan that I've been able to lose weight and stay on plan this long without feeling really tired & resentful (and regaining every blasted pound!). Love for Juddd is not a strong enough word for this girl!!! ITA with you, mint! :heart:


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:19 AM.