Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   JUDDD (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/)
-   -   Snacking - Let's talk (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/801616-snacking-lets-talk.html)

Mamatomany 04-09-2013 06:42 AM

Snacking - Let's talk
 
I have noticed that most of you jidders do not snack. You have three square meals. I WANNA BREAK MY SNACK HABIT. I have found myself feeling not satisfied and I just munch. It is always healthy, always LCD, lots of good fats, etc. is it a mental thing? How do I move past this? Any suggestions?

adillenal 04-09-2013 06:45 AM

I follow Richards, "Mastering Leptin", which has helped me eliminate snacking. There are other books about resetting Leptin but I have the Mastering Leptin book so that is what I follow. I always eat breakfast even on DD's and wait at least 6 hours before I have lunch. So basically I eat at 6, 12 and 6. And rarely eat after 7 if I end up having a later dinner. I was never a night eater anyway so that part has been the easiest. DH on the other hand lives in front of the frig after it gets dark.

I think the snack food industry in American has brain washed all of us into thinking we can't live if we don't snack. And of course the snack foods being touted are poor quality nutrition wise. Expensive junk. My opinion anyway.

gotsomeold 04-09-2013 07:06 AM

I ate more volume, gave myself permission to have a salad in mid-afternoon if I felt I needed it, and recited "hunger is not an emergency" until I believed it.

deedee 04-09-2013 07:12 AM

I'm such a snacker, I'd love to break that habit too. But I love having things to munch on.

Adi, I've never heard of that book. I don't even know what leptin is. Off to google it!

adillenal 04-09-2013 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deedee (Post 16362894)
I'm such a snacker, I'd love to break that habit too. But I love having things to munch on.

Adi, I've never heard of that book. I don't even know what leptin is. Off to google it!

Here are the rules which are explained in much detail but basically are really easy to follow.
Rule 1: Never eat after dinner. Allow eleven to twelve hours between dinner and breakfast. Never go to bed on a full stomach. Finish eating dinner at least three hours before bed.

Rule 2: Eat three meals a day. Allow five to six hours between meals. Do not snack.

Rule 3: Do not eat large meals. If you are overweight, always try to finish a meal when you are slightly less than full; the full signal will usually catch up in ten to twenty minutes. Eating slowly is important.

Rule 4: Eat a breakfast containing protein.

Rule 5: Reduce the amount of carbohydrates you eat.

KeirasMom 04-09-2013 08:18 AM

I've never really been a snacker. Lately, though, now that I'm in maintenance, I'm finding that I get snacky at night. This is new for me, and was worrying me at first (the fear of the dreaded re-gain!), but I think my body's telling me I need more. I've been giving in to the snacking and going over my calories lately, but I'm not gaining weight. I would like to curb it though, so I'm thinking about just raising my calories and having somewhat bigger meals. This is REALLY hard for me to do, though, not because I can't eat more, but because I'm afraid to. I may have to look into the leptin reset. Hmmm . . . .

mom23kids 04-09-2013 08:19 AM

I used to be a big night time snacker, especially when I read (one book could mean a whole can of pringles, all at once :o ). When I started JUDDD I knew that was something I had to work on, so I slowly cut back my eating window (on both dds and uds). Now I'm done eating by 7pm and I brush my teeth. After doing this for a couple months I've totally broken my night time snacking habit. I do have an afternoon snack at 2- on dds it's a cup of diet hot cocoa and on uds it's usually something sweet. Very rarely do I have a morning snack, but I have 140 calorie granola bars on standby when I do crave something.

Kimberli33 04-09-2013 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mom23kids (Post 16363036)
I used to be a big night time snacker, especially when I read (one book could mean a whole can of pringles, all at once :o ). When I started JUDDD I knew that was something I had to work on, so I slowly cut back my eating window (on both dds and uds). Now I'm done eating by 7pm and I brush my teeth. After doing this for a couple months I've totally broken my night time snacking habit. I do have an afternoon snack at 2- on dds it's a cup of diet hot cocoa and on uds it's usually something sweet. Very rarely do I have a morning snack, but I have 140 calorie granola bars on standby when I do crave something.

^this,I like to read and eat too...adds to the enjoyment factor...lol:laugh:I still like to eat while reading so I go for baby carrots and ranch or flavored sunflower seeds in the shell.

mom23kids 04-09-2013 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kimberli33 (Post 16363199)
^this,I like to read and eat too...adds to the enjoyment factor...lol:laugh:I still like to eat while reading so I go for baby carrots and ranch or flavored sunflower seeds in the shell.

Ooh, flavored sunflower seeds sound good! I'll have to look for these :)

Kimberli33 04-09-2013 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mom23kids (Post 16363222)
Ooh, flavored sunflower seeds sound good! I'll have to look for these :)

BBQ or pickle flavor are my favorite but ranch is good as well.

Flossyliz 04-09-2013 02:44 PM

Mastering Leptin was a lifesaver for me too. Before following the Richards' suggestions, I was almost constantly ravenous.
They taught me to always "pin down" carbs with some protein, which made a big difference.
They suggest that if at first it's difficult to leave at least 4 hours between meals, you lengthen the gap a little more each day.
I'm the opposite of Adi though. I usually avoid breakfast and eat later in the day.

SlowSure 04-09-2013 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeirasMom (Post 16363034)
I may have to look into the leptin reset. Hmmm . . . .

I think the last 20 years research into leptin is interesting and may eventually have some useful solutions for people.

There are several approaches to regulating or regaining leptin sensitivity and the one that suits people may vary with their motivation, practicalities or the state of their metabolism and blood work.

Adi has given a grand summary of Byron Richard's Mastering Leptin and its principles.

Jack Kruse's leptin reset Rx (on his website which I can't link but there is a non-commercial link to a list of resources and his writings that are very helpful: http://tinyurl.com/Dr-Kruse-References). Kruse makes some interesting arguments about leptin resistance and common metabolic derangements such as hypothyroidism and Hashimoto's.

The Kruse and Richard's approaches and principles are similar. Kruse advocates 50-75g of protein at breakfast rather than Richard's 35g and he suggests counting carbs (25-50g per day) if you're overweight, obese or have fat to lose. They have a difference of opinion about the wisdom of exercising during your leptin reset (crudely, Kruse doesn't approve of it until leptin sensitivity is regained because he believes it prolongs leptin resistance in the muscles).

The Rosedale Diet seems to be more concerned with harnessing the power of leptin for anti-ageing and longevity benefits. It recommends that the majority of calories should be derived from fat and advocates a comparatively modest protein intake. Among the principles, it suggests that it's OK to eat 3 meals and 2 snacks a day.

The programmes are all more alike than they are dissimilar and some of the differences seem like angels dancing on pinheads. If people are interested, it's worth looking to see which is most likely to meet your needs and fit in with your lifestyle.

SlowSure 04-09-2013 03:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flossyliz (Post 16363808)
Mastering Leptin was a lifesaver for me too. Before following the Richards' suggestions, I was almost constantly ravenous.
...
I'm the opposite of Adi though. I usually avoid breakfast and eat later in the day.

One of Kruse's arguments that attracted my attention was his insistence that people eat a very high protein breakfast in order to forestall hunger until the next scheduled mealtime. However, he said that although this works for people with the usual diurnal variations of cortisol (raised in the morning, lower in the evening), there are some people who have low cortisol in the morning and it's higher at night so their needs are different and a protein breakfast might not be optimal for them.

I'm an erratic sleeper so I always find it difficult to time breakfast.

adillenal 04-09-2013 03:17 PM

I don't push protein at breakfast but I do have eggs everyday and more of them on UD's. They are almost equally fat and protein so eggs work for me. Two eggs every DD for breakfast.

Kissa 04-09-2013 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gotsomeold (Post 16362877)
I ate more volume, gave myself permission to have a salad in mid-afternoon if I felt I needed it, and recited "hunger is not an emergency" until I believed it.

This is just what I was going to write. Learn to embrace that 'empty feeling'.

It is a perfectly norma,l healthy feeling. It will do us more good than harm.

It was a bit of a shock to me mentally and physically at first, after years of LC, but it is easy now.:high5:

sorenkkg 04-09-2013 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gotsomeold (Post 16362877)
I ate more volume, gave myself permission to have a salad in mid-afternoon if I felt I needed it, and recited "hunger is not an emergency" until I believed it.

I was never much of a snacker-- maybe 1 after work and before dinner, and sometimes right before bed-- but I've always known that was a bad idea, and tried to eliminate it. Unsuccessfully, but always tried.

On JUDDD, I'm definitely eliminating the nighttime snack. I finish eating at 8 or 9pm latest, and then I might have tea (Tip #1: tea) at the most.

When I first started, I had some nights where I could *not* get to sleep without a snack, so I had it. 1 turkey pepperette for 50 cals, or a piece of laughing cow for 25, like that.
And not just on DDs, but UDs too-- I really think cutting out before bed (or middle of the night) eating is KEY to my getting anywhere with weight loss.

Tip 2: go for bulk. I agree with Nancy above-- bulk up so each meal is more filling. And fiber takes a while to digest, so you'll feel full longer.

I'm not filling up with carbs though-- I've gone though some popcorn or pasta phases, enjoying my newfound freedom on JUDDD, but in the end, I do better with low-er carb stuff, so I'm back to cabbage stirfries, tofu shirataki noodles, a whole bag of steamed broccoli :yummy:

I think that over time, your tastes change. I don't believe that your stomach "shrinks" :doh: b/c that's not physiologically possible, but you can reset your fullness setpoint.

Ok, so, to summarize, my tips:

Bulk up with LC veggies at each meal.
Indulge in some tea between meals if you need something. Drink lots of fluids overall
Remember-- hunger is not an emergency. If you wait 20 minutes, have some water/tea, and get involved in an activity, you'll find it goes away :)

Oh-- and brush/floss your teeth before bed. Good for your teeth and you usually won't want to snack!

:) S.

Librarygirl 04-09-2013 05:33 PM

I snacked today. I bought these little individual serving bags of chips, different kinds, thinking it would be "better" than eating out of a large bag. No, it's not. :D I wanted to try every variety. I had three of them, then skipped lunch for a healthy piece of cake and ice cream.:p I was home today, so it was easier to get off track. When I'm at work, I have my lunch packed (usually) and I stick to it most of the time. Today I felt like I couldn't get full. Only now, after dinner and dessert do I finally feel like I can't eat any more. It's been about an hour since I had anything. I almost feel like it was the "suggestion" of hearing about others saying they felt like they had to eat more because the next day was a DD. I hadn't felt that way until I read about it.:laugh:

Hope you get the snacking monster under control! I need to do the same.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:26 PM.