Low Carb Friends

Low Carb Friends (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/)
-   JUDDD (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/)
-   -   DD's vs UP's (http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/juddd/772080-dds-vs-ups.html)

sherrymyra 05-19-2012 03:33 PM

DD's vs UP's
 
Hello. I have seen topics where people say they love their DD's. But does anyone just plain not like them? Are you out there?

I can live with them. And I will. I love the JUDD. But I still miss eating more on my DD's. As the day goes on I just tell myself, it's only one day. Tomorrow it is an UD. And that really works for me but I still feel a little deprived. :dunno:

Still I love how this is working for me and wouldn't do it any other way.

leonak 05-19-2012 03:38 PM

I am very much like you! :shake:

But this WOE does work!:hugs:

Scotty 05-19-2012 04:08 PM

I "get through" the DDs (341), and DON'T enjoy them, DON'T feel energized or calm or any of the wonderful things others feel.

However, I am much more disciplined about them and indeed stick to them even though I am headachey, light headed, and don't sleep.

It's the UDs that are difficult, even though I journal obsessively. I just tend to get going and eat and eat....and don't even ask me about when I drink "adult beverages"...

When I stick to the program, I lose. When I don't, I don't...:D

I like not having any restrictions, other than my own stupidity...:o:o

Becky 05-19-2012 04:10 PM

I'm getting used to them, but I still have a tough one every now and again and sometimes on a DD morning I feel a bit of dread before I get out of bed.

I have made up a schedule for my DDs that seems to make it so much easier, I wait till at least 1:30 to eat anything, I then eat 200 calories, then another 200 at 4:00, then another 200 at 7:00. I do 600 DDs, 500 DDs were killer.

b_lou_who 05-19-2012 04:10 PM

I like the empty feeling mostly. It's good

adillenal 05-19-2012 05:25 PM

I find them easy and actually prefer them to UD's. I had a good one today and worked hard all day loading and unloading and selling at a craft show all day. Lots of energy. drank lots of water. Thank goodness my booth was near the bathroom. Now tomorrow I will have problems about what to eat and then want everything I see.

sherrymyra 05-19-2012 05:44 PM

I wish I liked the empty feeling. Although honestly it's not so much that I am starving, as to wishing I could eat something. So it's a mental thing really. But I make do and then the next day is an UD. :)

Muffabuff 05-19-2012 07:16 PM

Addinenal, I believe you mentioned you have goats, I think. What do you sell at the craft fairs. Sorry off topic!

adillenal 05-19-2012 07:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Muffabuff (Post 15667330)
Addinenal, I believe you mentioned you have goats, I think. What do you sell at the craft fairs. Sorry off topic!

Yes, my hobby is raising and showing dairy goats. I have LaManchas, Saanens and Alpines. So they can eat all they want, I make goat milk soap and lotion and sell it at craft shows and festivals. I do all of the work and the goats just stand around and wait for their feed trough to fill up. :sad: BUT I love my goats. :love: And they love to eat so we get along well.
I have been peddling goat milk products for the past 5 years. Keeps me busy along with a fulltime job.

hockey_gal 05-19-2012 10:26 PM

I don't like DDs either. Occassionally I have "good" one but most of the time I don't like them. I dislike feeling hungry. I dislike the low energy feeling. But I disliked every day on LC diet so now I only dislike 3x/week...with 3 great days and one okay day :)

adillenal 05-20-2012 06:07 AM

I know this sounds backwards but the less I eat on DD's the more energy I have. And I do better with having 1/2 cup cooked groats with added oat fiber and gluc for breakfast. Keeps me going most of the day with a energy to spare. Took me awhile to find that perfect (for me) breakfast for DD's. No hunger either. But everyone is different about feeling hungry.

ellgee 05-20-2012 06:40 AM

I'm not a huge fan of DDs either but I have to admit they are simpler. The foods I eat on DDs are pretty much the same all the time so not a lot of thinking involved. But, no, don't particularly care for them.

Avicenna 05-20-2012 06:46 AM

I have a really hard time with DD's, especially this past week since I've been trying to give up my excessive caffeine habit (caffeine withdrawl + DD = very unpleasant). I finally decided to stop making myself so miserable and to allow anything in the 500-1000 range on a DD, although I'm also uneasy with that because in a sense it's more straightforward to stay with a 500 limit.

sherrymyra 05-20-2012 07:05 AM

Thanks for the feedback.

I was really wondering what everyone else felt about DD's since I don't particularly like them. You read people saying they love them and I was thinking, am I the only one who doesn't like them. Glad to see that I'm not.

I do like that it is only every other day and I can live with it.

sungoddess 05-20-2012 07:29 AM

I certainly don't love them. I was doing fine with them in the beginning. I felt energized, felt little hunger and didn't mind them. But as time went on into the third month, they became harder. I had some pretty hard DD's, feeling very hungry and low energy. I do them and get through them because I believe they are healing me. But I never wake up and say..."oh boy it is a down day! Yippeeeeee!":hyst:

sherrymyra 05-20-2012 07:36 AM

Exactly. :)

SoHappy 05-20-2012 08:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sherrymyra (Post 15666388)
Hello. I have seen topics where people say they love their DD's. But does anyone just plain not like them? Are you out there?

I can live with them. And I will. I love the JUDD. But I still miss eating more on my DD's. As the day goes on I just tell myself, it's only one day. Tomorrow it is an UD. And that really works for me but I still feel a little deprived. :dunno:

Still I love how this is working for me and wouldn't do it any other way.

LOL Well, the reason they are hard is because we are doing a *double-strength* diet on DDs, in exchange for not have to lower calories to weight loss diet level at all on UDs. Which, of course, you already know.

But just consciously staying aware of why those DD calories have to be as low as they are helps us stay the course. It's one day of very low calories... but it's accomplishes TWO days of dieting for weight loss!!!!!

If I HAVE to be on a weight loss diet every single day, I'll throw in the towel. I absolutely hate having to have reins and rules controlling my meals every single day! So I'm willing to do the dieting part doubly hard every other day, in exchange for the freedom from weight loss calorie levels on UDs. Really fair exchange for me. One I can be successful on and, more importantly, live with forever. 'Cause I know if I don't live within the parameters of some diet/plan forever, I will bloat back up to my previous size, and that's not the body I want to have to occupy. :laugh:

sherrymyra 05-20-2012 08:46 AM

You said it pretty well SoHappy.

Becky 05-20-2012 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adillenal (Post 15667340)
Yes, my hobby is raising and showing dairy goats. I have LaManchas, Saanens and Alpines. So they can eat all they want, I make goat milk soap and lotion and sell it at craft shows and festivals. I do all of the work and the goats just stand around and wait for their feed trough to fill up. :sad: BUT I love my goats. :love: And they love to eat so we get along well.
I have been peddling goat milk products for the past 5 years. Keeps me busy along with a fulltime job.

We had goats (nubians) throughout my childhood, we had goats milk constantly and occasionally goat meat which I loved!!

adillenal 05-20-2012 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Becky (Post 15668066)
We had goats (nubians) throughout my childhood, we had goats milk constantly and occasionally goat meat which I loved!!

Oh good. Another person with a goat interest. Raised my only child on goat milk and like to make kefir which I could not drink on LC but now I CAN. :jumpjoy: Love JUDDD for many reasons and being able to have healthy higher carb foods is GREAT.

I am one of those that likes DD's and I think the part I really like is not having to think or plan. I pretty much do the same thing every DD. In my mind I know that is the way it is going to be so DD's are non negotiable. Now UD's are another story.

sherrymyra 05-20-2012 10:17 AM

Quote:

I pretty much do the same thing every DD
I do too actually. I like not having to think about it. Just do it. I know how many calories I am getting this was so makes it easy.

Luna Loca 05-20-2012 10:40 AM

I am not a fan of DDs. Even on 700 calories, I don't look forward to them. They are something I need to do, but don't want to do, if that makes any sense. I don't do them because I want to, I do them because of the results I get.

I definitely prefer up days, though. Hey, I wasn't 300 pounds for no reason! I like to eat!

Kissa 05-20-2012 01:11 PM

I really do like a DD as a rule. On occasion they aren't pleasant. I am lucky I know.

casmira 05-21-2012 01:14 AM

I find them pretty variable. Most are fine, some are tough. Generally, my energy is the same up or down, and I might be slightly more easily irritated, but I can contain it - it's not that bad.

I quite like them.

What I like most about them is that my trousers are looser despite the fact that most of the time, I have a grand old time of it. The beauty of the DDs is that I never now worry or feel like I'm on an uncontrollable rollercoster towards a future of kaftans and elasticated waists if I enjoy a meal out or have a glass of wine and some crisps without obsessive planning and counting.

Terilynn 05-21-2012 05:33 AM

I won't say I HATE down days, but I sure don't love them.
I prefer the up days.... I actually prefer the up up and away days....which is why I am here. My husband doesn't like the down days either.

We just.... get through them the best we can. I would really like to be able to do a fast on down days, but so far that's not in the cards.

zipp2play 05-21-2012 05:36 AM

Down Days aren't my favorit, there are times that I am so hungry I shake and get irritable. On days like that, I eat a little more. If I can't function, that doesn't work! That being said, I enjoy up days, but do find getting in the calories is sometimes a chore. I find, after doing JUDDD for almost 5 week, food isn't constantly on my mind either day. Really odd for me!

practicemakeperfct 05-21-2012 07:21 AM

I am only 1 week in and today is my 4th DD, so keep that in mind.

I struggle from the time I wake up (530-6am) until around 1-2 in the afternoon on DD's. It is a consorted effort to not eat crap or drink sugary cream filled coffees. I am still toying with approaches to find what works best to get through my mornings...I've done high protein, fasting, bars, shakes....Today I just had an entire container of Gerber Graduates Puffs for breakfast. (150 calories). I;m happy right now but we'll see how that treats me in the next couple of hours. I have soup and a protein shake on standby.

Once I get to 2pm, whatever it is that makes me crave like crazy seems to turn off, and I am fine until the next day.

I am finding my UD's relatively difficult as well as I am trying to find balance to give myself permission to eat well without binging on crap on top of it. Junk food is my addiction. UGH. I try to keep it out of the house but I have 2 kids under 2 and 2 teenaged step kids. When the teenagers are around my husband loads to house with cookies, chips, ice cream, etc. Its so hard not snacking, and the "just one bite" thing doesnt work well for me either. Then the neightbor bringing over homemade cookies....well. I'll forgive him because those were good lol.

Anyway, this WOE is working better overall for me than low carb was because I like being able to have some freedoms to eat what I want without it screwing up ketosis for 3 days later.

buttoni 05-21-2012 08:03 AM

As I sit her with my stomach rumbling for the last half hour, I can't say I LIKE DD's, but I'm getting through them OK, and much better than in the beginning of my JUDDD adventure that began 6 weeks ago. Coffee at breakie and lunch usually curbs hunger until I get to my 500 calorie dinner, so I'm surprised at the stomach growling today. Must be because I dropped to my calculator number of 335 two DD's ago. First time I've really experienced stomach growling on a down day, so that MUST be what's causing this. I ate all my UD calories yesterday, so it sure should have prepared me for today. Hope I can make it to dinner before I cave today. That approach WAS working OK before the further calorie restriction I implemented this week.

vanilla_latte 05-21-2012 08:49 AM

I can say that 99% of the time I like them because I know that's when the "magic" is at work. I do have an occasional day when my desk plant looks particularly appetizing, however. As exhilerating as it is to welcome an UD, it can be work to get in enough calories in!!

I dredged up a thread I started awhile back on the positive aspects of a DD. It helps to ruminate on those things whilst the pinkie finger looks tempting. :laugh:

http://www.lowcarbfriends.com/bbs/ju...positives.html

Spank'd 05-21-2012 12:50 PM

I'm another one who simply tolerates them.

I do however, take a certain amount of satisfaction when I don't get hungry until later in the day. If I get hungry early, I think "Darnit! I'm hungry already! Now what do I have to do to make the hunger leave me alone until I can eat?"


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:21 PM.