Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study

jezzie · 06-12-2008, 01:51 PM

Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study

LONDON (Reuters) - A popular vitamin supplement aimed at diabetics is not as effective as most advertisements for it claim, Belgian researchers said on Thursday.

Their study published in the journal BioMed Central found that benfotiamine -- a synthetic derivative of the vitamin B1 -- does not actually dissolve and penetrate cell membranes as well as the researchers say is often claimed.

The findings highlight the problem of many widely available non-prescription medicines and supplements that are not regulated or vetted by scientific bodies.

"We studied the compound and found its properties were not as advertised," said Lucien Bettendorff, a biochemist at the University of Liege in Belgium, who led the study.

"It is said it is good for the brain but this is not the case, according to our study."

Vitamin B1, or thiamine, plays a key role in keeping cells healthy, and previous research has shown that diabetics have less of it in their blood.

Studies in mice have also suggested the synthetic compound could prevent blood vessel damage in diabetics. Bettendorff said his findings did not contradict these claims but noted such trials used very high doses of benfotiamine.

Instead, simple lab tests showed that benfotiamine as sold to consumers was not lipid-soluble -- which means it did not dissolve in organic solvents and oils to boost health by working quickly, he added.

The findings mean people who buy the supplement may be basing their decision on incorrect information because many manufacturers advertise benfotiamine as lipid-soluble, he added.

"It did not dissolve so it can't work its way through the membranes," Bettendorff said in a telephone interview. "This is clearly an error from a chemical point of view."

(Reporting by Michael Kahn; Editing by Maggie Fox and Mariam Karouny)

Reuters

Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study: Scientific American

Doggygirl · 06-13-2008, 12:44 PM

The word "synthetic" leaped off the page at me several times. I don't know a lot about supplements in general, B's in particular, or whether synthetic B's are an issue compared to natural forms.

Maybe I'm just sensitive to the issues of patents and synthetics v. natural forms of things as relates to $$$$$$$$...

Sorry...that was a mindless babble. Couldn't resist though...even though there is really not a point.

DG

06-12-2008, 01:51 PM	#1
jezzie Old Wise One Join Date: Oct 2000 Location: Hudson River Valley Posts: 38,597 Blog Entries: 77 Gallery: jezzie Stats: choosing to be scale-free; WOE: YOU:on a Diet - Dr. Oz Start Date: 04/22/07 - lightbulb; started YOU.	Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study LONDON (Reuters) - A popular vitamin supplement aimed at diabetics is not as effective as most advertisements for it claim, Belgian researchers said on Thursday. Their study published in the journal BioMed Central found that benfotiamine -- a synthetic derivative of the vitamin B1 -- does not actually dissolve and penetrate cell membranes as well as the researchers say is often claimed. The findings highlight the problem of many widely available non-prescription medicines and supplements that are not regulated or vetted by scientific bodies. "We studied the compound and found its properties were not as advertised," said Lucien Bettendorff, a biochemist at the University of Liege in Belgium, who led the study. "It is said it is good for the brain but this is not the case, according to our study." Vitamin B1, or thiamine, plays a key role in keeping cells healthy, and previous research has shown that diabetics have less of it in their blood. Studies in mice have also suggested the synthetic compound could prevent blood vessel damage in diabetics. Bettendorff said his findings did not contradict these claims but noted such trials used very high doses of benfotiamine. Instead, simple lab tests showed that benfotiamine as sold to consumers was not lipid-soluble -- which means it did not dissolve in organic solvents and oils to boost health by working quickly, he added. The findings mean people who buy the supplement may be basing their decision on incorrect information because many manufacturers advertise benfotiamine as lipid-soluble, he added. "It did not dissolve so it can't work its way through the membranes," Bettendorff said in a telephone interview. "This is clearly an error from a chemical point of view." (Reporting by Michael Kahn; Editing by Maggie Fox and Mariam Karouny) Reuters Vitamin supplement not as effective as ads say: study: Scientific American

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

06-13-2008, 12:44 PM	#2
Doggygirl Senior LCF Member Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: IL Posts: 511 Gallery: Doggygirl Stats: 204/146/145-150 size 18/8/10 WOE: Moderate Carbs + Curves Start Date: 5/22/08	The word "synthetic" leaped off the page at me several times. I don't know a lot about supplements in general, B's in particular, or whether synthetic B's are an issue compared to natural forms. Maybe I'm just sensitive to the issues of patents and synthetics v. natural forms of things as relates to $$$$$$$$... Sorry...that was a mindless babble. Couldn't resist though...even though there is really not a point. DG